"Amusing Ourselves to Death" sounds rather intense and it is. The first thing I thought of when I began to read this article by Neil Postman is my favorite album by Pink Floyd's Roger Waters called "Amused to Death." A very similar title. Much like Postman's article, Roger Waters emphasizes on the death and violence going on in the world and how people are becoming accustom towards these major issues by watching and listening to these articles on the T.V. and radio. The album cover is a photo of a monkey watching T.V. to emphasize the idea of "monkey see, monkey do." This shows how people are still animals deep down and how society has "been transformed into congenial adjuncts of show business, largely without protest or even much protest" (Postman 4). Amusing oneself to death means how the media is shaping our perception on other issues in the world. This may even include making us a lot more scared of an issue than we really should be. The media likes to expand on these issues and really blow them out of proportions. Most Americans have grown indifferent to the issues of the world and we truly "are the people amusing ourselves to death" (Postman 3).
Postman makes a claim that cosmetics have replaced ideology. He refers to the Kennedy and Nixon election and how Nixon was "sabotaged by makeup men" (Postman 4) because of the way he looked. Kennedy brought forth a youthful and refreshing spirit to politics, just by the way he appeared on the television. This idea of popularity through entertainment is a huge factor in the way people elect officials and business leaders. When President Taft was elected in 1909, T.V. was nonexistent and photographs were just becoming a lot more common. In today's world, America would not elect a President of such obesity as he was, even though, "The shape of a man's body is largely irrelevant to the shape of his ideas" (Postman 7). This is the society in which television has created for all Americans and the rest of the world.
Las Vegas is not the focus point of American spirit. In fact, Las Vegas is looked at as American corruption in my opinion. It is the gambling capital as well as the center for strip clubs and other degrading sexual activities. American spirit should be focused around opportunity and determination, not purely entertainment. "Las Vegas is a city entirely devoted to the idea of entertainment" (Postman 3) which is not what American spirit is all about.
I agree with Postman's idea that photos are a type of metaphor. On the other hand, I disagree with his idea that pictures "classify the world for us" (Postman 10). Take the Middle East for example. Any time the Middle East shows up in Fox News or CNN or whatever, photographs that are taken or video clips made always have guns, bombs, or dead bodies scattered everywhere. These images are not a metaphor for the rest of the Middle East. Having lived in Qatar myself, I can honestly tell you that it is one of the cleanest and friendliest places I have ever been. America has fallen under this idea of photos representing entire areas which this is not completely the case. We can not "confuse a message with a metaphor" (Postman 10) if we truly want to understand the world.
Roger Waters, Richard Nixon, Las Vegas, and the issues in the Middle East are all examples of how our society is amusing itself to death. We are growing more and more immune to horrible news and more and more focused on the aesthetics of how people look compared to their actual intelligence. This may eventually lead to the downfall of our American society if we amuse ourselves to death.
David,
ReplyDeleteYou seem to have made some really creative observations and connections about Americans amusing themselves to death. Pink Floyd's Roger Water and the album he created truly model how the American society has followed the media and their opinions ever since the introduction of the television. We wait for the headlines to be released, watch the media blow them out of proportion, and waver on our own views on specific issues. You also made an interesting point about Postman's claim on the real reason Kennedy beat out Nixon, which was due to Kennedy's appearance and youthful spirit on television. There was a study conducted on picking the winners of gubernatorial and senatorial races that you might find interesting. People were asked to pick the face with more competence, without knowing that they were running for political office. I think the results should interest you, so I will post the link if you want to see.
http://www.science20.com/news_account/picking_election_winner_by_appearance_accurate_70_percent_of_the_time
David, I think you did a really great job with this blog. I thoroughly enjoyed your analysis of the Pink Floyd album and the “monkey see, monkey do” concept portrayed in the cover for said album. Your analysis of Postman’s claims was spot on, for the most part. I did disagree with you about Las Vegas and the idea of entertainment and the American Spirit. While I agree with you that it certainly is not the focal point of American spirit at its core, I think that being the entertainment capital certainly brings it closer to that objective. When you say that entertainment “is not what the American spirit is all about,” I think that we have to reexamine what the American spirit truly is during this Age of Entertainment. Traditionally, you are right, entertainment doesn’t encapsulate the ideals of America, but today, with the Internet and loads of media to distract us, does it? You hinted at this during your essay, but I think this question is loaded enough to merit further examination.
ReplyDeleteDavid, I really like this blog and the information that you put into it. The breaking down of the meaning of the Pink Floyd album and then tying it to the chapter of Postman's in my eyes was perfect. I also agree with you that all this shows that how as a society we are "dependent" on the flash and the headlines in life. But I also do think that because of this it would be unreasonable to think that Las Vegas isn't the representation of the American Spirit. Where the American Spirit might have pointed to New York previously in my opinion the amount of corruption and dependency on technology in today's society leads to cities like Las Vegas to be much sounder representations of our "American Spirit"
ReplyDelete